Guide
First Message on a Dating Site: Openers That Get a Reply
Ask about something they wrote, keep it short, and let the conversation earn the next step. Here's how, with examples.
What should a first message actually say?
Ask about one specific thing in their profile, add a line about yourself, and end on a question that's easy to answer. That's the whole trick. Anyone can type "hey". A question about the horror double bill in their bio proves you read past the photos and gives them something to say back.
People with an alternative look have heard every lazy opener going: the "who died?" joke, the "cheer up, it might never happen", the remark about the outfit from someone who never got past it. Asking a real question is a low bar. Clearing it gets you noticed.
Openers that work, and why they do
The shape is notice, share, ask. Notice something they chose to put on their profile. Share a line about you, so it doesn't feel like an interview. Ask something that takes more than "yes" to answer. Use these as templates, not scripts:
- "Your bio says Saturdays are a gig or a horror film. Which won last weekend? Mine was a double bill and I regret nothing."
- "You sew your own corsets? Respect. How long did the first one take? My only sewing project is a patch held on by hope."
- "Is the moth on your arm part of a bigger piece? I've been planning a sleeve for ages and still can't choose an artist."
- "So what are you listening to? Your profile says darkwave, but everyone has one old album they still know every word of."
None of these is clever. They work because they're about the person reading them, and they can be answered on a phone in a queue. If your own profile gives people nothing to ask about, the profile tips will fix that first.
Short of ideas? Our questions to ask a goth double as a bank of openers, sorted from easy to deep.
What not to send, and the one thing never to send
2cool2date is 18+ and flirting is half the fun, but a first message is a hello, not a proposition. These sink a conversation before it starts:
- Copy-paste lines
- People can tell. A line that could go to anyone reads like it went to everyone, and gets the reply it deserves.
- One-word openers
- "Hey", "hi" and "u up?" hand all the work to the other person. Give them something to answer.
- Comments on their body
- Even the ones meant as compliments. Praise their choices instead: the boots, the hair colour they clearly worked for, their taste in films. Asking about a tattoo's story is fine; remarks about the body it's on are not.
- Photos nobody asked for
- Never. Not as a joke, not to "break the ice". Ask before you share any image. The site blurs images that might be explicit behind a warning, but that's a safety net, not permission, and an unwanted photo is a quick way to get blocked and reported.
- Pressure
- "Why aren't you answering?" an hour later. People have jobs, lives and gigs to get to.
A look is never an invitation. A corset, a collar or a profile photo in latex tells you about someone's style, not what they want from you, and the person wearing it decides.
Pacing: how fast to reply and when to stop
Match their rhythm. If they write three lines a day, a wall of text every ten minutes feels like a lot; if they're quick and chatty, being quick back is fine. There's no prize for playing it cool, so don't sit on a reply for hours to look busy.
No answer? One friendly follow-up after a few days is plenty. After that, silence is your reply, and it's rarely personal: people get busy, change their minds or meet someone at a gig. Members who reliably reply earn a badge for it, which is a nice thing to have next to your name.
Not sure the interest is mutual? Our guide to the signs a goth likes you covers what real effort looks like in messages.
The Free plan comes with a daily message limit, which is one more reason to make each one count. The pricing page explains the plans.
Letting someone down kindly takes one click
You won't want to say yes to everyone, and you don't owe anyone an essay. 2cool2date has one-click polite replies for exactly this: a clear, kind "thanks, but no" that spares them a week of refreshing their inbox.
On the receiving end, take it well. No arguing, no "why not?", no second try next month. "No" means move on, and anyone who won't can be blocked instantly and reported from inside the site.
When to suggest meeting up
When replies are getting longer, questions are going both ways and a shared interest has turned up, suggest meeting in person. Make it specific, short and public: coffee after dark, an afternoon in a record shop, a smaller gig. "There's a late horror screening on Friday, fancy it?" is easier to answer than "we should hang out sometime".
Make "not yet" an easy answer, and mean it. For more ideas, see alternative date ideas, and read meeting safely before you go: somewhere busy, a friend who knows the plan, and your own way home.
After something casual rather than anything serious? Say so before you meet. Our casual dating tips show how to raise it without making it awkward.
Why the chat stays on the site until you're ready
Your number and your social accounts give away far more than a username does. On the site, blocking is instant, you can report anyone from inside the site, and you're warned if someone tries to shift the conversation onto another app. Swap details when you've decided to meet and you trust them, not because someone pushed.
Pushing to leave the site early is also a classic sign of a dating scam, usually followed by a sad story that ends in a request for money, gift cards or bank details. Never send any of them. The safety page has more on spotting and reporting scams, and our dating guides cover the rest.
What people ask about first messages
What should I say to a goth in a first message?
Whatever you'd say to anyone whose profile caught your eye: pick something they wrote and ask about it. Skip anything about vampires or funerals; they've heard it all, usually from a stranger at a summer barbecue. Music, films, style and their corner of the scene are all good ground, and the goth dating page has more.
How do I start a conversation on a dating app without it being awkward?
Lead with a question about something they chose to share, then add a line about yourself so it's a two-way chat. Awkwardness mostly comes from generic openers. A specific one gives you both something to talk about.
How long should a first message be?
Two to four lines. Long enough to show you read their profile, short enough to answer on a bus. Save the full history of your record collection for when they ask.
Should I wait for them to message first?
No need. Anyone can make the first move, whoever they are and whoever they're interested in. If a profile makes you grin, say so with a question.
When should I give someone my number?
When you've arranged to meet and you trust them. Until then, keep talking on 2cool2date, where you can block and report anyone, and the site can warn you if someone tries to move you elsewhere.
Go On, Say Something Interesting
Make your profile, find someone whose bio raises a question, and ask it.
Join free